Skip to main content

Supreme Court Verdict Revives Ban On Tobacco Items In Tamil Nadu

Supreme Court Verdict Revives Ban On Tobacco Items In Tamil Nadu

The Supreme Court on Tuesday stayed a Madras Court verdict banning on tobacco items in Tamil Nadu.

New Delhi:

The Supreme Court on Tuesday stayed a Madras High Court verdict quashing a May 2018 notification prohibiting sale, manufacture and transport of gutkha and other tobacco-based products in Tamil Nadu.

A bench of justices KM Joseph and BV Nagarathna stayed the high court verdict dated January 20.

"We are of the view that the petitioner (Tamil Nadu) has made out a case to stay the impugned judgment with regard to paragraph 13," the bench said.

In the event the manufacturers have a case that their activities are not covered by the notification issued by the state, they may approach the appropriate forum seeking redressal, it added.

Senior advocate Kapil Sibal and Additional Advocate General Amit Anand Tiwari, appearing for the Tamil Nadu government, said health is a state subject and the state government has every right to take care of the health of its citizens.

Mr Sibal said that a number of health problems due to chewing of tobacco pose a huge burden on the state exchequer and the ban was imposed on sale, manufacture and transport of gutkha and other tobacco-based products based on the directive of the apex court.

Several senior lawyers, including CS Vaidyanathan, appeared for the firms engaged in the trade of gutkha and pan masala.

On March 4, the top court sought a response to a plea challenging an order of the Madras High Court quashing the May 2018 notification.

It had sought response from the food safety commissioner, Jayavilas Tobacco Traders and others on the plea filed by the Tamil Nadu government.

Mr Tiwari, appearing for the state, argued that orders of the food safety commissioner banning sale, storage, manufacture of gutkha and other tobacco products are backed by Regulation 2.3.4 of the Food Safety and Standards (Prohibition and Restriction on Sales) Regulations, 2011.

The high court had set aside the notification issued by the food safety commissioner on May 23, 2018, banning manufacture, storage, transport, distribution and sale of gutkha, pan masala and other chewable food products containing tobacco or nicotine as ingredients.

It had held that allowing the food safety commissioner to impose a permanent ban on tobacco products by issuing successive notifications year after year would amount to conferring a power that was not provided in the law.

Holding that tobacco, with or without additives, is a food product, the high court had held that notifications banning gutkha and pan masala in Tamil Nadu issued by the food safety commissioner are not within his powers and quashed the same.

The state government in its appeal filed by advocate on record TS Sabarish and drawn by advocate Devyani Gupta said that the high court held that tobacco, with or without additives, is a food product as defined under Section 3(1)(j) of the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006.

It said that the high court erroneously held that notifications banning gutkha and pan masala in the state issued by the food safety commissioner under Regulation 2.3.4 of the 2011 regulations are not within his powers and quashed the same.

"This court has on several previous occasions expressed its approval of banning gutkha, pan masala and other related products, in view of several concerns, inter alia, related health issues, plastic waste generation etc," it said.

The appeal said that it is also pertinent to mention at the outset that Regulation 2.3.4 of the 2011 regulations also clearly prohibits the use of tobacco or nicotine in any food products and this regulation has not been challenged by the respondents herein (tobacco traders firms).

It said that pursuant to the views expressed by this court, and in order to further ensure the implementation of the prohibition, the state passed orders under Section 30(2) of the Food Safety and Standards Act banning manufacture, storage, transport, distribution or sale of gutkha and pan masala, flavoured or scented food products or chewable food products by whatever name called, whether packaged or unpackaged and/or sold as one product, or through packaged as separate products, sold or distributed in such a manner so as to easily facilitate mixing by the consumer and any other food containing tobacco or nicotine as ingredients.

"These orders under Section 30(2) are valid for 1 year only and at the expiry of such period, the State of Tamil Nadu passed similar order afresh to ensure that the ban continues," it said.

The appeal added that the reports have found that consuming smokeless tobacco or chewing tobacco have number of harmful effects and it further causes various cancerous diseases like oral premalignant lesions/conditions, oral cancer, oesophageal cancer, stomach cancer, pancreatic cancer, throat (pharynx and larynx) cancer, in addition to non-cancerous conditions.

(Except for the headline, this story has not been edited by NDTV staff and is published from a syndicated feed.)

Adblock test (Why?)



from NDTV News- Special https://ift.tt/sGT0Fgj https://ift.tt/T8Igm7n
via IFTTT

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

North Korea Says It Tested New Strategic Cruise Missile

North Korea test-fired a new generation of strategic cruise missile on Wednesday. (Representational) Seoul: North Korea fired several cruise missiles towards the Yellow Sea on Wednesday, Seoul's military said, the latest in a series of tension-raising moves by the nuclear-armed state. Hours later, North Korea appeared to confirm the firing, saying it had carried out its first test of a new generation of strategic cruise missiles it is developing, the Pulhwasal-3-31. Pyongyang has accelerated weapons testing in the new year, including tests of what it called an "underwater nuclear weapon system" and a solid-fuelled hypersonic ballistic missile. "Our military detected several cruise missiles launched by North Korea towards the Yellow Sea at around 7:00 am today," the South Korean Joint Chiefs of Staff said in a statement. Unlike their ballistic counterparts, the testing of cruise missiles is not banned under current UN sanctions against Pyongyang. Cruise...

18-Year-Old Killed By Friends Over Mobile Game Password In Bengal: Cops

According to cops, accused "friends" attempted to burn the victim after killing him. (Representational) Kolkata: An argument over sharing the password of an online mobile game allegedly led to the murder of a teenage boy by four of his friends in West Bengal's Murshidabad district, a senior police officer said. The body of 18-year-old Papai Das, who had been missing since January 8, was discovered near Nishindra Ghat of the feeder canal in Farakka on Monday, police said. Papai, a class 10 student, was reportedly killed by his four "close" friends after a disagreement over sharing the password for a mobile online game. The accused individuals have been arrested, police added. "These five individuals used to play online games at one of the quarters of the Farakka Barrage. The victim went out on the evening of January 8 and never returned. On January 9, the family lodged a police complaint. "Based on preliminary investigations, we discovered that...

"Jaiswal Has Run Ahead Of Gill": Ex-India Star's Massive T20 WC Verdict

Former India opener Aakash Chopra has suggested that Yashasvi Jaiswal is slightly ahead of Shubman Gill in the pecking order as captain Rohit Sharma's partner at the top in T20Is. Since making his debut last year, Jaiswal has been in stunning form in the shortest format of the game. Gill's form, on the other hand, has dipped since the ODI World Cup last year in India. With the T20 World Cup scheduled to be held later this year, Chopra feels Jaiswal will open the innings with Rohit during the tournament. "It's clear that Yashasvi Jaiswal has run ahead of Shubman Gill. Yashasvi is ahead in the two-horse race, Gill is lagging slightly behind. Gill was played in the first match, dropped in the second, and wasn't played in the third as well," Chopra said on his YouTube channel. Jaiswal helped India beat Afghanistan in the second T20I earlier this week, scoring a quickfire fifty. Considering his recent form across formats, Chopra emphasised that Jaiswal has ...